Riddles today — GST

Parrot 3

Tota: GST is being passed ! A great Reform since 1991 !                Myna1
Myna: Since 1950, actually?
Tota: Why 1950?
Myna: Because the states which had agreed on a constitution to form India will lose
some of their autonomy and independence.
Tota: Why do you say that?
Myna: I don`t say it. See for yourself … GST is a Constitutional amendment, requiring
2/3 votes in Parliament, no? It is not just another law.
Tota: Hm … But a consensus has been reached !
Myna: This consensus was always there. The long haggling was only to take political
Tota: OK. But it will benefit the nation, no?
Myna: It will benefit the seths, sure, but not the people.
Tota: Why do you say that? Isn`t unifying the taxes and also the tax rates across the
different states a good idea?
Myna: It probably is …
Tota: And scores of different check points for different taxes at the inter-state borders
will be removed. Less delays, less corruption … Isn`t it for the good?
Myna: It probably is …
Tota: And won`t the avoidance of double/triple taxation from the successive stages of
production — to wholesale – to retail sale reduce the total tax for the consumer?
Myna: For those who keep “number ek” accounts it certainly will. For the “number do”
walas …
Tota: OK, OK … But won`t the buying public pay less now?
Myna: No.
Tota: Why not?
Myna: Because the seths, at each stage, will not reduce the prices to pass on the tax
Tota: ?
Myna: Yes. Prices are high not only due to high taxes but also due to high profits. No?
Tota: Oh … So what will be achieved by GST?
Myna: Govt`s tax revenues will decrease; seth`s profits will increase; people will suffer
as usual.
Tota: Hm … But at least the potential will be created to pass on the benefit to the
people… No?
Myna: Yes. And many such potentials were created since 1947. They have remained …
well … potential.
Tota: ?
Myna: No?


About ctaposh

Cartoonist, poet, novelist, social activist, development banker, documentary filmmaker, blogger, reader of books and realities, ponderer of questions milling around.
This entry was posted in clues, crony capitalism, Humour, Indian elite class, private profit, reality-check, Trends and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.